FrançaisCVS Health vs UnitedHealth Group: which stock to buy?
Head to head
| Metric | CVS Health | UnitedHealth Group | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $90.33 | $411 | |
| Median target (12m) | $113 (+25%) | $498 (+21%) | |
| Analyst reliability (1y) | 41% | 47% | 🔵 UNH |
| Avg gain / call (1y) | +8% | +11% | |
| P/E | 23.8 | 23.5 | 🔵 UNH |
| $1000 invested (10y ago) | $1,071 | $3,533 | 🔵 UNH |
Performance by year
| Year | CVS | UNH | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | +39% | +26% | 🟢 CVS |
| 2025 | +32% | -35% | 🟢 CVS |
| 2024 | -24% | -4% | 🔵 UNH |
| 2023 | -16% | -1% | 🔵 UNH |
| 2022 | -17% | +6% | 🔵 UNH |
| 2021 | +49% | +43% | 🟢 CVS |
| 2020 | +6% | +19% | 🔵 UNH |
| 2019 | +3% | +18% | 🔵 UNH |
| 2018 | -17% | +13% | 🔵 UNH |
| 2017 | -0% | +38% | 🔵 UNH |
| 2016 | -18% | +36% | 🔵 UNH |
Frequently asked questions
CVS Health or UnitedHealth Group: which to buy?
Over ~10 years, CVS Health returned $1,071 on $1000 vs $3,533 for UnitedHealth Group, and UnitedHealth Group has better analyst reliability. Not advice: also check valuation (P/E) and your horizon.
CVS Health vs UnitedHealth Group: which performed best?
Over ~10 years, UnitedHealth Group wins ($1,071 vs $3,533 on $1000 invested, price return excluding dividends).
CVS Health vs UnitedHealth Group: which is cheaper?
On P/E, UnitedHealth Group is cheaper (23.8 vs 23.5). A lower P/E isn't always a better deal (growth matters).
What is JPI Invest?
JPI Invest aggregates analyst recommendations across the entire S&P 500 (plus the S&P MidCap 400), replays them against real prices and measures who predicts best — on results, not reputation. Instead of taking a price target at face value, you see each analyst's track record on each stock.
- 🏆 Analyst leaderboard by real reliability (beating their sector, not just riding the rally)
- 🎯 What to buy: 3 backtested methods over 6 years, from cautious to aggressive
- 💬 AI assistant: ask anything about any stock, with the numbers
- 📊 Portfolio tracking + 🔔 price alerts by email
⚠️ Educational information, not investment advice. Past price performance (excluding dividends). Data: Yahoo Finance.